November 18, 2026

The Common App Made Applying to College Easier. It's Time to Make It Harder Again.

Opinion | By Sunny Grewal, Founder & CEO, StrivePath


The Common App is one of the worst things to happen to college admissions.


That might be a strange position to take as someone who runs a college advising company. But I'm increasingly convinced that a system designed to make college applications easier has actually made the admissions process considerably worse.


And I think we need to do something that will make plenty of people uncomfortable: limit students to 15 college applications. Period.


We've created an admissions arms race


In the 2015–16 admissions cycle, students submitted approximately 3.9 million applications through the Common App. By 2025–26, that number had climbed to 10.8 million.


That's an increase of roughly 176%.


Importantly, the number of students applying hasn't grown nearly as quickly. The average applicant now submits 7.06 applications through Common App, compared with approximately 4.7 a decade earlier.


We've made it easier to apply, and students have responded by applying to more schools.


The problem is that college admissions isn't happening in isolation. It's happening in an environment where students are constantly comparing themselves with their peers.


If a classmate applies to 20 colleges, why shouldn't I? What if I don't get into my top choices? What if I need a few more reaches?


Before long, applying to 20 or 25 schools starts feeling less like an excessive strategy and more like a necessary precaution.


And so the cycle continues.


More applications don't necessarily mean better outcomes


Consider a student applying to 15 highly selective universities, each with an acceptance rate below 10%.


Adding five more highly selective colleges doesn't improve that student's chances at any of the original 15. It simply creates five additional opportunities, each with its own low probability of admission.


Of course, applying to more schools can improve the likelihood of receiving at least one acceptance, particularly when students build balanced lists.


But that's different from the prevailing mentality that applying to more prestigious institutions is somehow a substitute for developing a thoughtful college list.


Meanwhile, application volumes increase, published acceptance rates can decline, and students become even more anxious about their prospects.


We have effectively created a system where everyone feels compelled to do more, even when doing more isn't necessarily producing better results.


Colleges aren't benefiting from this either


Colleges must evaluate increasingly large application pools while trying to predict which admitted students will actually enroll. A student can only attend one institution. Yet that student may submit applications to 20 or more.


This creates uncertainty for admissions offices and makes enrollment management increasingly complicated.


Binding Early Decision offers colleges one way to reduce that uncertainty. But it comes with a tradeoff for students: those admitted through binding programs generally lose the opportunity to compare competing financial aid offers before committing.


Application growth isn't the sole reason colleges use Early Decision, but the broader problem is clear.


Students want more options. Colleges want more certainty. And the resulting incentives don't always serve families particularly well.


My proposal: A national limit of 15 applications


Common App already imposes a limit of 20 colleges on its own platform. But students can submit additional applications through the University of California, California State University, institutional portals, and other systems.


That's not a meaningful systemwide limit.


I'd advocate for a national cap of 15 undergraduate applications per student, regardless of which application platform they use.


That number isn't sacred. It's a starting point for a serious policy discussion.


Fifteen applications should provide sufficient room for a thoughtful combination of likely, target, and reach schools for most students.


There would need to be carefully designed exceptions for students facing unusual financial circumstances, specialized academic requirements, or other situations where additional applications are genuinely necessary.


We also need to recognize that restricting applications could disadvantage students who lack access to good college advising. Any reform would need to include better college information, transparent admissions data, and meaningful support for students building their lists.


But those challenges shouldn't prevent us from addressing the larger problem.


We need to stop confusing access with volume


I recognize the Common App has done considerable good. It has reduced administrative barriers, expanded access, and made applying to college more manageable for millions of students.


Those accomplishments deserve recognition. But increasing the number of applications isn't the same as improving the college admissions experience.


At StrivePath, we encourage students to think carefully about where they want to spend four years of their lives. What environments will help them thrive? What can their families afford? Which institutions offer the academic and personal experiences they're looking for?


Those questions deserve more attention than simply figuring out how many additional applications can be submitted before a deadline.


We've created an admissions culture where students feel compelled to maximize their options, colleges struggle to manage increasingly unpredictable applicant pools, and families spend months worrying about outcomes they have limited ability to control.


The solution isn't necessarily to make applying to college even easier.


Maybe it's time to make students apply to fewer colleges—and give them better reasons for choosing the ones they do.


Because the goal of college admissions shouldn't be to collect as many acceptance letters as possible. 


It should be to find somewhere worth attending.


Ready to build your student's plan?


StrivePath offers personalized academic and college advising for Bay Area and Orange County students from 7th grade through senior year. Book a free consultation with our team today.

High school students sitting in a circle with laptops talking during a group discussion
By Sunny Grewal • November 18, 2026
See how Tri-Valley high schools rank in 2026-27, including Dougherty Valley, Monte Vista, San Ramon Valley, Amador Valley, Foothill, and Dublin High School.
Group of smiling high school students standing in a school hallway with backpacks and books
By Sunny Grewal • November 18, 2026
See how San Jose and South Bay high schools rank in 2026-27, including Lynbrook, Monta Vista, Cupertino, Saratoga, Los Gatos, and Leland High School.
By Joy Mercado • October 22, 2026
See how Fremont and Marin high schools rank in 2026-27, including Mission San Jose, American, Irvington, Redwood, and Tamalpais High School.
By Sunny Grewal, Founder of StrivePath • October 8, 2026
Choosing a public high school in North Orange County? Compare Troy, Sunny Hills, Valencia, and Yorba Linda using the latest rankings and college prep data.
By Sunny Grewal, Founder of StrivePath • October 7, 2026
Top rankings don't always mean better college admission chances. Learn what Irvine and Central OC's 2026-27 school rankings reveal for students and parents.
By Sunny Grewal, Founder of StrivePath • October 6, 2026
See how Santa Ana and West OC high schools rank in 2026-27, including La Quinta, Pacifica, and Segerstrom, and what the results mean for college admissions.
By Sunny Grewal, Founder of StrivePath • October 5, 2026
See how Tesoro, San Juan Hills, Aliso Niguel, and other South Orange County high schools rank in 2026-27 and what the results mean for college admissions.
By Sunny Grewal, Founder of StrivePath • October 4, 2026
Compare 2026-27 high school rankings for Laguna Beach, Corona del Mar, and Huntington Beach. See how school performance relates to college readiness.
By Sunny Grewal • August 24, 2026
Yale, Cornell, UNC, and more dropped supplemental essays for 2026-27. See the full list and what students need to do differently this application cycle.
By Sunny Grewal • August 20, 2026
Early Decision admit rates look great until you remove recruited athletes. See which 15 colleges give non-athletes a real ED advantage, and when ED is the wrong move.